Loading... Please wait...

Choosing a Speaker (15 June 2009)

Parliament is again the centre of attention as we consider who our next Speaker will be. I have decided which will not be getting my vote but I have not yet decided who will get it.

Tradition suggests (but does not dictate) that a Conservative should take the post. Sir Alan Haselhurst, my choice ten years ago, is an excellent Chairman and a safe pair of hands, but is he too late? I have worked under Sir George Young on the Standards Committee. He would be acceptable without being exciting.

John Bercow, a Tory with more support on the Labour benches than his own, would be an interesting choice. He has moved from the right wing libertarian to liberal egalitarian over ten years, a competent if eccentric character. A radical step too far?

On Labour’s side Margaret Beckett was a very good Leader of the House and would push for reforms. But has she been a minister too recently to be attractive to backbenchers?

These are the four I am considering. Of the others, Anne Widdecombe would be temporary and has a ‘celebrity’ streak unbecoming in a Speaker. Frank Field is too dry and may struggle. The others do not have what it takes to be a modern Speaker in an outward-looking Parliament.

The Speaker must be a friend to backbenchers whilst acknowledging the Government’s duty to govern. He or she must now also be the voice of the public on the way we conduct ourselves.

As I have said elsewhere, change in our democracy must come. Parliament must be a party to that change, not exercising power merely for the sake of it. Giving up power is like breaking the habit of a lifetime or, in Westminster’s case, a millennium. It’s like giving up smoking: very difficult and stressful to do, but making us all healthier once it is done.

Want to comment?
Sort comments by: latest conversation | latest top level comment


Caroline Cotton
Message left at 01:42 pm, Mon 22nd Jun 2009
We must never forget, the callous incompetance of Margaret Beckett drove farmers to bankruptcy and suicide. An appalling choice to help clean up Parliament.
Options: reply to this message | report this message as offensive
ian johnson
Message left at 08:51 pm, Sat 20th Jun 2009
Incredibly bad judgement, three of the four you consuider have been tied up in the expenses scandal - Tom, what planet are you on ? Haselhurst - he was the MP even the Telegraph were so outraged about they put up their own deputy editor against him. You next go for this toff George Young 'the Old Etonian chairman of the standards and privileges committee claimed £127,159 between 2001 and 2008 for his flat in Victoria, within walking distance of the House of Commons' next to Bercow - God forbid - John Bercow, the Conservative MP who has declared himself a candidate in the race to become the next speaker, is to pay more than £6,500 to HM Revenue & Customs after he confirmed that he had not paid capital gains tax when he sold two properties in 2003. Beckitt - 16k on on hanging flowers.... You are supporting the rogues/thieves - I want someone of integrity as Speaker - Field or Widdecombe would be equally good. You are out of your depth, still clinging onto & protecting the incomplete redaction you voted for. Pathetic Ian Johnson
Options: reply to this message | report this message as offensive
Marty
Message left at 07:58 am, Fri 19th Jun 2009
'A safe pair of hands' Have you forgotten that this committee presided over the expenses cover up? You genuinely think that Westminster got away with this don't you? When is the General Election?
Options: reply to this message | report this message as offensive
Promoted by Ray Collins, General Secretary, the Labour Party, on behalf of the Labour Party, both at 39 Victoria Street, London, SW1H 0HA.
Powered by taobase from Tangent Labs. Hosted by Rackspace, 2 Longwalk Road, Stockley Park, Uxbridge, UB11 1BA.